Furnished Finder vs Craigslist: Where Should You List?

The demand for short- and mid-term rentals is booming—thanks to travel nurses, remote workers, digital nomads, and relocating professionals.

As a landlord or property owner, listing your furnished rental in the right place can mean the difference between constant occupancy and long vacancy periods.

But with so many platforms out there, two of the most talked-about options are Furnished Finder and Craigslist. So, which one should you trust with your listing?

In this guide, we’ll break down the pros and cons of each, helping you decide which platform best suits your rental strategy.

Overview of Furnished Finder

Furnished Finder is a listing platform designed specifically for mid-term furnished rentals—typically 30 days or longer.

It’s become especially popular among travel nurses, contract workers, and remote professionals who need clean, reliable housing without the commitment of a 12-month lease.

Key Features:

• Tenant screening tools

• No booking fees

• Direct communication with renters

• Map-based property search

• Landlord dashboard with messaging & calendar

Who It’s Best For:

• Landlords offering furnished, mid-term stays (30+ days)

• Properties near hospitals, business hubs, or universities

• Owners who want qualified leads over high-volume, short stays

Cost to List:

• $99/year per property (flat fee)

• No commissions or service fees taken from your rent

Listing Process:

• Create an account

• Upload photos, details, and availability

• Listings are reviewed before going live (usually within 24 hours)

Furnished Finder is not instant-booking like Airbnb—it’s more of a lead generation tool, letting you choose and vet who stays in your property.

Overview of Craigslist

Craigslist has been a go-to classifieds site for decades. While not a specialized rental platform, it’s still widely used for everything from apartment rentals to garage sales.

Key Features:

• Simple, no-frills interface

• Broad reach across cities and regions

• Instant posting (no review process)

• Very little vetting or moderation

Who Typically Uses It:

• People looking for budget housing, sublets, and quick move-ins

• A mix of short-, long-, and mid-term renters

• Those who prefer local, person-to-person arrangements

Cost to List:

• $5 per listing in most U.S. markets

• Listing expires after 30 days, so ongoing visibility requires reposting

Pros:

• Inexpensive and easy to use

• Broad, immediate exposure

• Great for testing demand in new areas

Cons:

• High volume of spam or scam inquiries

• Listings often lack trust-building details

• No tenant screening or support tools

Key Differences Between Furnished Finder and Craigslist

Which Platform is Right for You?

It depends on your property type, location, and ideal tenant.

Choose Furnished Finder if:

• You offer furnished, mid-term rentals

• You want reliable, pre-screened tenants

• Your unit is near hospitals or business hubs

• You prefer a set-it-and-forget-it model with minimal reposting

Choose Craigslist if:

• You want to reach a broad, local audience

• You’re okay filtering through leads manually

• You’re listing a budget or unfurnished unit

• You don’t mind renewing listings regularly

Some savvy landlords use both platforms—Furnished Finder for quality leads, and Craigslist for quick visibility.

Tips for Success on Either Platform

Do:

• Use high-quality, well-lit photos

• Write clear and detailed descriptions (include rent, lease terms, and amenities)

• Respond to inquiries quickly and professionally

• Screen tenants thoroughly (especially on Craigslist)

Don’t:

• Post vague or misleading information

• Share personal information before vetting the renter

• Forget to update availability and pricing

Bonus Tip: On Craigslist, include watermarked photos and use a burner phone/email to avoid spam. On Furnished Finder, keep your calendar up to date for better placement.

Both Furnished Finder and Craigslist have their place in the rental world. If you’re offering a furnished unit for 30 days or more and want peace of mind with tenant quality, Furnished Finder is a smart investment.

If you’re looking for quick exposure and local reach, Craigslist still delivers—but be ready to filter out the noise.

At the end of the day, the best platform is the one that helps you rent faster, with less hassle, and to the kind of tenant you want.

Also Read

How to Find Section 8 Approved Homes Near You

Top 10 Sites Like RentCafe for Apartment Hunters